Visual demands in modern Australian primary school classrooms

Sumithira Narayanasamy, Stephen J. Vincent, Geoff P. Sampson, Joanne M. Wood

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: The visual demands of modern classrooms are poorly understood yet are relevant in determining the levels of visual function required to perform optimally within this environment. Methods: Thirty-three Year 5 and 6 classrooms from eight south-east Queensland schools were included. Classroom activities undertaken during a full school day (9am to 3pm) were observed and a range of measurements recorded, including classroom environment (physical dimensions, illumination levels), text size and contrast of learning materials, habitual working distances (distance and estimated for near) and time spent performing various classroom tasks. These measures were used to calculate demand-related minimum criteria for distance and near visual acuity, contrast and sustained use of accommodation and vergence. Results: The visual acuity demands for distance and near were 0.33±0.13 and 0.72±0.09 logMAR, respectively (using habitual viewing distances and smallest target sizes) or 0.33±0.09 logMAR assuming a 2.5 times acuity reserve for sustained near tasks. The mean contrast levels of learning materials at distance and near were greater than 70 per cent. Near tasks (47 per cent) dominated the academic tasks performed in the classroom followed by distance (29 per cent), distance to near (15 per cent) and computer-based (nine per cent). On average, children engaged in continuous near fixation for 23±5 minutes at a time and during distance-near tasks performed fixation changes 10±1 times per minute. The mean estimated habitual near working distance was 23±1 cm (4.38±0.24 D accommodative demand) and the vergence demand was 0.86±0.07Δ at distance and 21.94±1.09Δ at near assuming an average pupillary distance of 56mm. Conclusions: Relatively high levels of visual acuity, contrast demand and sustained accommodative-convergence responses are required to meet the requirements of modern classroom environments. These findings provide an evidence base to inform prescribing guidelines and develop paediatric vision screening protocols and referral criteria.

Original languageEnglish
JournalClinical and Experimental Optometry
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2016

Fingerprint

Visual Acuity
Vision Screening
Learning
Queensland
Lighting
Contrast Media
Referral and Consultation
Guidelines
Pediatrics

Keywords

  • Children's vision
  • Learning
  • Vision

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ophthalmology
  • Optometry

Cite this

Visual demands in modern Australian primary school classrooms. / Narayanasamy, Sumithira; Vincent, Stephen J.; Sampson, Geoff P.; Wood, Joanne M.

In: Clinical and Experimental Optometry, 2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{3bffc33a3fc54815b14f1169087bb751,
title = "Visual demands in modern Australian primary school classrooms",
abstract = "Background: The visual demands of modern classrooms are poorly understood yet are relevant in determining the levels of visual function required to perform optimally within this environment. Methods: Thirty-three Year 5 and 6 classrooms from eight south-east Queensland schools were included. Classroom activities undertaken during a full school day (9am to 3pm) were observed and a range of measurements recorded, including classroom environment (physical dimensions, illumination levels), text size and contrast of learning materials, habitual working distances (distance and estimated for near) and time spent performing various classroom tasks. These measures were used to calculate demand-related minimum criteria for distance and near visual acuity, contrast and sustained use of accommodation and vergence. Results: The visual acuity demands for distance and near were 0.33±0.13 and 0.72±0.09 logMAR, respectively (using habitual viewing distances and smallest target sizes) or 0.33±0.09 logMAR assuming a 2.5 times acuity reserve for sustained near tasks. The mean contrast levels of learning materials at distance and near were greater than 70 per cent. Near tasks (47 per cent) dominated the academic tasks performed in the classroom followed by distance (29 per cent), distance to near (15 per cent) and computer-based (nine per cent). On average, children engaged in continuous near fixation for 23±5 minutes at a time and during distance-near tasks performed fixation changes 10±1 times per minute. The mean estimated habitual near working distance was 23±1 cm (4.38±0.24 D accommodative demand) and the vergence demand was 0.86±0.07Δ at distance and 21.94±1.09Δ at near assuming an average pupillary distance of 56mm. Conclusions: Relatively high levels of visual acuity, contrast demand and sustained accommodative-convergence responses are required to meet the requirements of modern classroom environments. These findings provide an evidence base to inform prescribing guidelines and develop paediatric vision screening protocols and referral criteria.",
keywords = "Children's vision, Learning, Vision",
author = "Sumithira Narayanasamy and Vincent, {Stephen J.} and Sampson, {Geoff P.} and Wood, {Joanne M.}",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1111/cxo.12365",
language = "English",
journal = "The Australasian journal of optometry",
issn = "0817-881X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Visual demands in modern Australian primary school classrooms

AU - Narayanasamy, Sumithira

AU - Vincent, Stephen J.

AU - Sampson, Geoff P.

AU - Wood, Joanne M.

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Background: The visual demands of modern classrooms are poorly understood yet are relevant in determining the levels of visual function required to perform optimally within this environment. Methods: Thirty-three Year 5 and 6 classrooms from eight south-east Queensland schools were included. Classroom activities undertaken during a full school day (9am to 3pm) were observed and a range of measurements recorded, including classroom environment (physical dimensions, illumination levels), text size and contrast of learning materials, habitual working distances (distance and estimated for near) and time spent performing various classroom tasks. These measures were used to calculate demand-related minimum criteria for distance and near visual acuity, contrast and sustained use of accommodation and vergence. Results: The visual acuity demands for distance and near were 0.33±0.13 and 0.72±0.09 logMAR, respectively (using habitual viewing distances and smallest target sizes) or 0.33±0.09 logMAR assuming a 2.5 times acuity reserve for sustained near tasks. The mean contrast levels of learning materials at distance and near were greater than 70 per cent. Near tasks (47 per cent) dominated the academic tasks performed in the classroom followed by distance (29 per cent), distance to near (15 per cent) and computer-based (nine per cent). On average, children engaged in continuous near fixation for 23±5 minutes at a time and during distance-near tasks performed fixation changes 10±1 times per minute. The mean estimated habitual near working distance was 23±1 cm (4.38±0.24 D accommodative demand) and the vergence demand was 0.86±0.07Δ at distance and 21.94±1.09Δ at near assuming an average pupillary distance of 56mm. Conclusions: Relatively high levels of visual acuity, contrast demand and sustained accommodative-convergence responses are required to meet the requirements of modern classroom environments. These findings provide an evidence base to inform prescribing guidelines and develop paediatric vision screening protocols and referral criteria.

AB - Background: The visual demands of modern classrooms are poorly understood yet are relevant in determining the levels of visual function required to perform optimally within this environment. Methods: Thirty-three Year 5 and 6 classrooms from eight south-east Queensland schools were included. Classroom activities undertaken during a full school day (9am to 3pm) were observed and a range of measurements recorded, including classroom environment (physical dimensions, illumination levels), text size and contrast of learning materials, habitual working distances (distance and estimated for near) and time spent performing various classroom tasks. These measures were used to calculate demand-related minimum criteria for distance and near visual acuity, contrast and sustained use of accommodation and vergence. Results: The visual acuity demands for distance and near were 0.33±0.13 and 0.72±0.09 logMAR, respectively (using habitual viewing distances and smallest target sizes) or 0.33±0.09 logMAR assuming a 2.5 times acuity reserve for sustained near tasks. The mean contrast levels of learning materials at distance and near were greater than 70 per cent. Near tasks (47 per cent) dominated the academic tasks performed in the classroom followed by distance (29 per cent), distance to near (15 per cent) and computer-based (nine per cent). On average, children engaged in continuous near fixation for 23±5 minutes at a time and during distance-near tasks performed fixation changes 10±1 times per minute. The mean estimated habitual near working distance was 23±1 cm (4.38±0.24 D accommodative demand) and the vergence demand was 0.86±0.07Δ at distance and 21.94±1.09Δ at near assuming an average pupillary distance of 56mm. Conclusions: Relatively high levels of visual acuity, contrast demand and sustained accommodative-convergence responses are required to meet the requirements of modern classroom environments. These findings provide an evidence base to inform prescribing guidelines and develop paediatric vision screening protocols and referral criteria.

KW - Children's vision

KW - Learning

KW - Vision

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84959900457&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84959900457&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/cxo.12365

DO - 10.1111/cxo.12365

M3 - Article

C2 - 26889920

AN - SCOPUS:84959900457

JO - The Australasian journal of optometry

JF - The Australasian journal of optometry

SN - 0817-881X

ER -