Pembingkaian berita persempadanan camar bulan dan tanjung datu, kalimantan barat

Translated title of the contribution: The framing of news on the border of camar bulan and tanjung datu, west kalimantan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

This study attempted to look at the on line news in Kompas. com and Utusan Online on news slant, news framing, and the factors that influence the framing process on the border issue between Camar Bulan and Tanjung Datu. Qualitative content analysis and indepth interview were used to achieve the purpose of this research. The four framing functions based on the model forwarded by Entman (1993), namely, problem definition, causal interpretation, moral evaluation, and treatment recommendation were discretely carefully analysed. Research results from Kompas. com revealed news that are dynamic, contemporary edging towards war journalism as opposed to peace and neutral while Utusan Online has the attributes of normative, traditional and neutral as opposed to war. In the framing process Kompas.com and Utusan Online stand on nationalism as the most vital element in constructing news framing on border. The framing factor on the news on border as reported by Kompas.com and Utusan Online is influenced by internal factors which include news value, nationalism, meaningful reporting practice, media agenda setting, media control, media ownership the philosophy and basic media, the reaction towards foreign media and the reporter’s individual understanding. External factors include reading interest, media system, the norms and journalism method, the history of Indonesia- Malaysia, commercialization, propaganda and interest group, anti- Malaysia sentiments, foreign news agency, and interest of the people and nation and internal politics. This research contributes to the existence of nationalism as a vital element in news reporting that involves the nation. Nationalism becomes the main element in both moral evaluation and influence factor. It is concluded here that nationalism plays a crucial role in the news reporting about the shared borders of Indonesia and Malaysia. Although journalism ethics advocates objectivity, reporter’s subjectivity is still involved in news that involves a nation. Subjectivity comes in the form of nationalism.

Original languageMalay
Pages (from-to)341-370
Number of pages30
JournalJurnal Komunikasi: Malaysian Journal of Communication
Volume31
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

news
nationalism
journalism
Malaysia
reporter
Indonesia
subjectivity
news value
news agency
media system
objectivity
propaganda
commercialization
evaluation
research results
interest group
content analysis
peace
moral philosophy
interpretation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Communication

Cite this

@article{d543fd1cd5ae4d77828ffac0d440cdd0,
title = "Pembingkaian berita persempadanan camar bulan dan tanjung datu, kalimantan barat",
abstract = "This study attempted to look at the on line news in Kompas. com and Utusan Online on news slant, news framing, and the factors that influence the framing process on the border issue between Camar Bulan and Tanjung Datu. Qualitative content analysis and indepth interview were used to achieve the purpose of this research. The four framing functions based on the model forwarded by Entman (1993), namely, problem definition, causal interpretation, moral evaluation, and treatment recommendation were discretely carefully analysed. Research results from Kompas. com revealed news that are dynamic, contemporary edging towards war journalism as opposed to peace and neutral while Utusan Online has the attributes of normative, traditional and neutral as opposed to war. In the framing process Kompas.com and Utusan Online stand on nationalism as the most vital element in constructing news framing on border. The framing factor on the news on border as reported by Kompas.com and Utusan Online is influenced by internal factors which include news value, nationalism, meaningful reporting practice, media agenda setting, media control, media ownership the philosophy and basic media, the reaction towards foreign media and the reporter’s individual understanding. External factors include reading interest, media system, the norms and journalism method, the history of Indonesia- Malaysia, commercialization, propaganda and interest group, anti- Malaysia sentiments, foreign news agency, and interest of the people and nation and internal politics. This research contributes to the existence of nationalism as a vital element in news reporting that involves the nation. Nationalism becomes the main element in both moral evaluation and influence factor. It is concluded here that nationalism plays a crucial role in the news reporting about the shared borders of Indonesia and Malaysia. Although journalism ethics advocates objectivity, reporter’s subjectivity is still involved in news that involves a nation. Subjectivity comes in the form of nationalism.",
keywords = "Border news, Conflict, Framing, Nasionalism, News issue",
author = "Ruslan Ramli and Chang, {Peng Kee} and {Shahrul Nazmi}, Sannusi",
year = "2015",
language = "Malay",
volume = "31",
pages = "341--370",
journal = "Jurnal Komunikasi: Malaysian Journal of Communication",
issn = "2289-151X",
publisher = "Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Pembingkaian berita persempadanan camar bulan dan tanjung datu, kalimantan barat

AU - Ramli, Ruslan

AU - Chang, Peng Kee

AU - Shahrul Nazmi, Sannusi

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - This study attempted to look at the on line news in Kompas. com and Utusan Online on news slant, news framing, and the factors that influence the framing process on the border issue between Camar Bulan and Tanjung Datu. Qualitative content analysis and indepth interview were used to achieve the purpose of this research. The four framing functions based on the model forwarded by Entman (1993), namely, problem definition, causal interpretation, moral evaluation, and treatment recommendation were discretely carefully analysed. Research results from Kompas. com revealed news that are dynamic, contemporary edging towards war journalism as opposed to peace and neutral while Utusan Online has the attributes of normative, traditional and neutral as opposed to war. In the framing process Kompas.com and Utusan Online stand on nationalism as the most vital element in constructing news framing on border. The framing factor on the news on border as reported by Kompas.com and Utusan Online is influenced by internal factors which include news value, nationalism, meaningful reporting practice, media agenda setting, media control, media ownership the philosophy and basic media, the reaction towards foreign media and the reporter’s individual understanding. External factors include reading interest, media system, the norms and journalism method, the history of Indonesia- Malaysia, commercialization, propaganda and interest group, anti- Malaysia sentiments, foreign news agency, and interest of the people and nation and internal politics. This research contributes to the existence of nationalism as a vital element in news reporting that involves the nation. Nationalism becomes the main element in both moral evaluation and influence factor. It is concluded here that nationalism plays a crucial role in the news reporting about the shared borders of Indonesia and Malaysia. Although journalism ethics advocates objectivity, reporter’s subjectivity is still involved in news that involves a nation. Subjectivity comes in the form of nationalism.

AB - This study attempted to look at the on line news in Kompas. com and Utusan Online on news slant, news framing, and the factors that influence the framing process on the border issue between Camar Bulan and Tanjung Datu. Qualitative content analysis and indepth interview were used to achieve the purpose of this research. The four framing functions based on the model forwarded by Entman (1993), namely, problem definition, causal interpretation, moral evaluation, and treatment recommendation were discretely carefully analysed. Research results from Kompas. com revealed news that are dynamic, contemporary edging towards war journalism as opposed to peace and neutral while Utusan Online has the attributes of normative, traditional and neutral as opposed to war. In the framing process Kompas.com and Utusan Online stand on nationalism as the most vital element in constructing news framing on border. The framing factor on the news on border as reported by Kompas.com and Utusan Online is influenced by internal factors which include news value, nationalism, meaningful reporting practice, media agenda setting, media control, media ownership the philosophy and basic media, the reaction towards foreign media and the reporter’s individual understanding. External factors include reading interest, media system, the norms and journalism method, the history of Indonesia- Malaysia, commercialization, propaganda and interest group, anti- Malaysia sentiments, foreign news agency, and interest of the people and nation and internal politics. This research contributes to the existence of nationalism as a vital element in news reporting that involves the nation. Nationalism becomes the main element in both moral evaluation and influence factor. It is concluded here that nationalism plays a crucial role in the news reporting about the shared borders of Indonesia and Malaysia. Although journalism ethics advocates objectivity, reporter’s subjectivity is still involved in news that involves a nation. Subjectivity comes in the form of nationalism.

KW - Border news

KW - Conflict

KW - Framing

KW - Nasionalism

KW - News issue

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84955159497&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84955159497&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 341

EP - 370

JO - Jurnal Komunikasi: Malaysian Journal of Communication

JF - Jurnal Komunikasi: Malaysian Journal of Communication

SN - 2289-151X

IS - 2

ER -