First results from ideal 2-D MHD reconstruction

Magnetopause reconnection event seen by Cluster

Teh Wai Leong, B. U Ö Sonnerup

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We have applied a new reconstruction method (Sonnerup and Teh, 2008), based on the ideal single-fluid MHD equations in a steady-state, two-dimensional geometry, to a reconnection event observed by the Cluster-3 (C3) spacecraft on 5 July 2001, 06:23 UT, at the dawn-side Northern-Hemisphere magnetopause. The event has been previously studied by use of Grad-Shafranov (GS) reconstruction, performed in the deHoffmann-Teller frame, and using the assumption that the flow effects were either negligible or the flow was aligned with the magnetic field. Our new method allows the reconstruction to be performed in the frame of reference moving with the reconnection site (the X-line). In the event studied, this motion is tailward/equatorward at 140 km/s. The principal result of the study is that the new method functions well, generating a magnetic field map that is qualitatively similar to those obtained in the earlier GS-based reconstructions but now includes the reconnection site itself. In comparison with the earlier map by Hasegawa et al. (2004), our new map has a slightly improved ability (ccCombining double low line0.979 versus ccCombining double low line0.975) to predict the fields measured by the other three Cluster spacecraft, at distances from C3 ranging from 2132 km (C1) to 2646 km (C4). The new field map indicates the presence of a magnetic X-point, located some 5300 km tailward/equatorward of C3 at the time of its traversal of the magnetopause. In the immediate vicinity of the X-point, the ideal-MHD assumption breaks down, i.e. resistive and/or other effects should be included. We have circumvented this problem by an ad-hoc procedure in which we allow the axial part of convection electric field to be non-constant near the reconnection site. The new reconstruction method also provides a map of the velocity field, in which the inflow into the wedge of reconnected field lines and the plasma jet within it can be seen, and maps of the electric potential and of the electric current distribution. Even though the velocity map is expected to be inaccurate near the X-point, it provides high-quality predictions (ccCombining double low line0.969) of the velocity components at points along the path of C1, some of which are close to the X-point; the predictions of density and pressure are less good. Except near the reconnection site, the new reconstruction provides a complete characterization, in unprecedented detail, of the entire dynamic plasma and field equilibrium, reconstructed from the C3 data. It represents our best prediction to date of what the actual configuration was like. But, since substantial time variations were present in the event, the recovered structure by necessity includes considerable time aliasing. The invariant direction used in the reconstruction, is found to agree, within 6°, with a recent theoretical prediction of the X-line orientation by Swisdak and Drake (2007).

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2673-2684
Number of pages12
JournalAnnales Geophysicae
Volume26
Issue number9
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2008
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

magnetopause
prediction
predictions
spacecraft
magnetic field
plasma
plasma equilibrium
Northern Hemisphere
current distribution
electric current
magnetic fields
plasma jets
wedges
electric field
inflow
convection
velocity distribution
breakdown
geometry
electric fields

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)
  • Atmospheric Science
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

First results from ideal 2-D MHD reconstruction : Magnetopause reconnection event seen by Cluster. / Wai Leong, Teh; Sonnerup, B. U Ö.

In: Annales Geophysicae, Vol. 26, No. 9, 01.09.2008, p. 2673-2684.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{cc176d1d72cc4cbca828e5345a6ebc2a,
title = "First results from ideal 2-D MHD reconstruction: Magnetopause reconnection event seen by Cluster",
abstract = "We have applied a new reconstruction method (Sonnerup and Teh, 2008), based on the ideal single-fluid MHD equations in a steady-state, two-dimensional geometry, to a reconnection event observed by the Cluster-3 (C3) spacecraft on 5 July 2001, 06:23 UT, at the dawn-side Northern-Hemisphere magnetopause. The event has been previously studied by use of Grad-Shafranov (GS) reconstruction, performed in the deHoffmann-Teller frame, and using the assumption that the flow effects were either negligible or the flow was aligned with the magnetic field. Our new method allows the reconstruction to be performed in the frame of reference moving with the reconnection site (the X-line). In the event studied, this motion is tailward/equatorward at 140 km/s. The principal result of the study is that the new method functions well, generating a magnetic field map that is qualitatively similar to those obtained in the earlier GS-based reconstructions but now includes the reconnection site itself. In comparison with the earlier map by Hasegawa et al. (2004), our new map has a slightly improved ability (ccCombining double low line0.979 versus ccCombining double low line0.975) to predict the fields measured by the other three Cluster spacecraft, at distances from C3 ranging from 2132 km (C1) to 2646 km (C4). The new field map indicates the presence of a magnetic X-point, located some 5300 km tailward/equatorward of C3 at the time of its traversal of the magnetopause. In the immediate vicinity of the X-point, the ideal-MHD assumption breaks down, i.e. resistive and/or other effects should be included. We have circumvented this problem by an ad-hoc procedure in which we allow the axial part of convection electric field to be non-constant near the reconnection site. The new reconstruction method also provides a map of the velocity field, in which the inflow into the wedge of reconnected field lines and the plasma jet within it can be seen, and maps of the electric potential and of the electric current distribution. Even though the velocity map is expected to be inaccurate near the X-point, it provides high-quality predictions (ccCombining double low line0.969) of the velocity components at points along the path of C1, some of which are close to the X-point; the predictions of density and pressure are less good. Except near the reconnection site, the new reconstruction provides a complete characterization, in unprecedented detail, of the entire dynamic plasma and field equilibrium, reconstructed from the C3 data. It represents our best prediction to date of what the actual configuration was like. But, since substantial time variations were present in the event, the recovered structure by necessity includes considerable time aliasing. The invariant direction used in the reconstruction, is found to agree, within 6°, with a recent theoretical prediction of the X-line orientation by Swisdak and Drake (2007).",
author = "{Wai Leong}, Teh and Sonnerup, {B. U {\"O}}",
year = "2008",
month = "9",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "26",
pages = "2673--2684",
journal = "Annales Geophysicae",
issn = "0992-7689",
publisher = "European Geosciences Union",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - First results from ideal 2-D MHD reconstruction

T2 - Magnetopause reconnection event seen by Cluster

AU - Wai Leong, Teh

AU - Sonnerup, B. U Ö

PY - 2008/9/1

Y1 - 2008/9/1

N2 - We have applied a new reconstruction method (Sonnerup and Teh, 2008), based on the ideal single-fluid MHD equations in a steady-state, two-dimensional geometry, to a reconnection event observed by the Cluster-3 (C3) spacecraft on 5 July 2001, 06:23 UT, at the dawn-side Northern-Hemisphere magnetopause. The event has been previously studied by use of Grad-Shafranov (GS) reconstruction, performed in the deHoffmann-Teller frame, and using the assumption that the flow effects were either negligible or the flow was aligned with the magnetic field. Our new method allows the reconstruction to be performed in the frame of reference moving with the reconnection site (the X-line). In the event studied, this motion is tailward/equatorward at 140 km/s. The principal result of the study is that the new method functions well, generating a magnetic field map that is qualitatively similar to those obtained in the earlier GS-based reconstructions but now includes the reconnection site itself. In comparison with the earlier map by Hasegawa et al. (2004), our new map has a slightly improved ability (ccCombining double low line0.979 versus ccCombining double low line0.975) to predict the fields measured by the other three Cluster spacecraft, at distances from C3 ranging from 2132 km (C1) to 2646 km (C4). The new field map indicates the presence of a magnetic X-point, located some 5300 km tailward/equatorward of C3 at the time of its traversal of the magnetopause. In the immediate vicinity of the X-point, the ideal-MHD assumption breaks down, i.e. resistive and/or other effects should be included. We have circumvented this problem by an ad-hoc procedure in which we allow the axial part of convection electric field to be non-constant near the reconnection site. The new reconstruction method also provides a map of the velocity field, in which the inflow into the wedge of reconnected field lines and the plasma jet within it can be seen, and maps of the electric potential and of the electric current distribution. Even though the velocity map is expected to be inaccurate near the X-point, it provides high-quality predictions (ccCombining double low line0.969) of the velocity components at points along the path of C1, some of which are close to the X-point; the predictions of density and pressure are less good. Except near the reconnection site, the new reconstruction provides a complete characterization, in unprecedented detail, of the entire dynamic plasma and field equilibrium, reconstructed from the C3 data. It represents our best prediction to date of what the actual configuration was like. But, since substantial time variations were present in the event, the recovered structure by necessity includes considerable time aliasing. The invariant direction used in the reconstruction, is found to agree, within 6°, with a recent theoretical prediction of the X-line orientation by Swisdak and Drake (2007).

AB - We have applied a new reconstruction method (Sonnerup and Teh, 2008), based on the ideal single-fluid MHD equations in a steady-state, two-dimensional geometry, to a reconnection event observed by the Cluster-3 (C3) spacecraft on 5 July 2001, 06:23 UT, at the dawn-side Northern-Hemisphere magnetopause. The event has been previously studied by use of Grad-Shafranov (GS) reconstruction, performed in the deHoffmann-Teller frame, and using the assumption that the flow effects were either negligible or the flow was aligned with the magnetic field. Our new method allows the reconstruction to be performed in the frame of reference moving with the reconnection site (the X-line). In the event studied, this motion is tailward/equatorward at 140 km/s. The principal result of the study is that the new method functions well, generating a magnetic field map that is qualitatively similar to those obtained in the earlier GS-based reconstructions but now includes the reconnection site itself. In comparison with the earlier map by Hasegawa et al. (2004), our new map has a slightly improved ability (ccCombining double low line0.979 versus ccCombining double low line0.975) to predict the fields measured by the other three Cluster spacecraft, at distances from C3 ranging from 2132 km (C1) to 2646 km (C4). The new field map indicates the presence of a magnetic X-point, located some 5300 km tailward/equatorward of C3 at the time of its traversal of the magnetopause. In the immediate vicinity of the X-point, the ideal-MHD assumption breaks down, i.e. resistive and/or other effects should be included. We have circumvented this problem by an ad-hoc procedure in which we allow the axial part of convection electric field to be non-constant near the reconnection site. The new reconstruction method also provides a map of the velocity field, in which the inflow into the wedge of reconnected field lines and the plasma jet within it can be seen, and maps of the electric potential and of the electric current distribution. Even though the velocity map is expected to be inaccurate near the X-point, it provides high-quality predictions (ccCombining double low line0.969) of the velocity components at points along the path of C1, some of which are close to the X-point; the predictions of density and pressure are less good. Except near the reconnection site, the new reconstruction provides a complete characterization, in unprecedented detail, of the entire dynamic plasma and field equilibrium, reconstructed from the C3 data. It represents our best prediction to date of what the actual configuration was like. But, since substantial time variations were present in the event, the recovered structure by necessity includes considerable time aliasing. The invariant direction used in the reconstruction, is found to agree, within 6°, with a recent theoretical prediction of the X-line orientation by Swisdak and Drake (2007).

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=51749110449&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=51749110449&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 26

SP - 2673

EP - 2684

JO - Annales Geophysicae

JF - Annales Geophysicae

SN - 0992-7689

IS - 9

ER -